Share
The Black Plastic Bag: A Tale of Caution, Correction and Context:
Concerns regarding potential toxicity of black plastic spatulas have sparked quite a debate after a study suggested such utensils made out of recycled black plastic could be leaching hazardous levels of toxic flame retardants into food. Though the study was modified upon realizing a dosage miscalculation by a factor of ten, it managed to bolster our curiosity and caution around the world of plastic recycling. But should we panic? Probably not, but we can certainly learn a lot from this faux pas. Here's all you need to know.
The Maturing Ventures of the Dark Plastic:
Once shunned by recycling facilities due to their color (which made them optically invisible to the sensors used to sort different plastics), recycled black plastic products are now gradually regaining acceptance with improved technologies and pigment alternatives. However, the past notoriety of black plastic has diverted some of its demand to be met by electronic waste, known to be treated with flame retardants that are toxic at high exposure levels.
The Original Study: A Slip in Decimal Position:
The original paper conducted by Chemosphere had assessed the levels of a flame-retardant chemical (BDE-209) in black plastic household products. Alarmingly, they concluded that kitchen utensils equated a daily dose of 34,700 ng, which was deemed to be hazardous. However, the misunderstanding was rooted in a miscalculation from the original study which overestimated the safe exposure limit advised by the US Environmental Health Protection Agency (EPA) by a factor of 10.
The amended circumstances and the Perspective:
With the rectification of the error, the estimated BDE-209 exposure was brought down to less than a tenth of the EPA’s recommended limit. Which means, our black kitchenware might be safer than we feared. But it does remind us of the complexity in managing the tradeoffs between sustainability and product safety.
The Bigger Concerns:
Though black spatulas might cause some concern, there are more pressing issues in our plastic usage that need immediate attention. For instance, the rise in the usage of PFAS (forever chemicals) in plastic food packaging, clothing, cosmetics, etc., that are increasingly making their way into human bodies. Or, the unseen microplastics flowing into our water systems and beyond which can serve as vectors for other harmful chemicals. There are bigger fish to fry in the plastic world, and our focus should be on putting the lid back on these 'unseen' threats.
We hope you enjoyed this article. Please feel free to leave a comment below if you want to engage in the discussion.
If you want to read more like this, make sure to check out our Blog and follow us on Instagram. If you are interested in truly sustainable products, check out our Shop.
Check out the original source here.